MyFox
 

Steve Says

by Steve_Noviello from Right here, 24/7

Last Post 9 days, 9 hours Ago


Our first homework assignment of the year was at the request of viewers like you.  You want to know where to find the best prices on school supplies.

I had a feeling there would be a price difference, but just HOW MUCH of a price difference really surprised me.

We shopped three stores- Walmart, Office Max and Kroger.   Each chosen to represent ONE segment of the shopping market- a deep discounter, office supply store, and supermarket.  We certainly know our list of sources is not comprehensive.

ON THE DAY THAT WE SHOPPED prices were as follows:  (PLEASE NOTE: penny prices at Office Max were part of a promotional sale- Walmart has indicated they would match the advertised penny price.  an * indicates that the item was not the same brand name, but instead the cheapest item we could find.)

#2 Pencils:

Walmart- $.50/10

Office Max- $1.49/10

Kroger- $.99/10

 

Crayola Crayons (24 count)

Walmart- $.22

Office Max- $1.29

Kroger- $1.99

 

Crayola Markers (10 count)

Walmart- $.88

Office Max- $2.99

Kroger- $3.49

 

*Ruler

Walmart- $.97

Office Max- $.01

Kroger- $.99

 

Westcott Scissors

Walmart- $1.97

Office Max- $2.49

Kroger- $2.49

 

4 Pack Highlighters

Walmart- $1.50

Office Max- $1.49

Kroger- $2.49

 

Construction Paper

Walmart- $1.43

Office Max- $1.99

Kroger- $1.99

 

Mead 5 Star 1 subject Spiral Notebook

Walmart- $1.97

Office Max- $4.99

Kroger- $4.99

 

*150 count notebook paper- wide ruled

Walmart- $.50

Office Max- $.15

Kroger- $1.00

 

11/2" 3 Avery 3 Ring Binder

Walmart- $3.67

Office Max- $4.79

Kroger $6.79

 

PROS FOR EACH STORE:

Walmart- Cheapest prices plus price match guarantee

Office Max- Perks program where teachers get paid back for student spending, plus specializes sales staff and penny promotions which change weekly.

Kroger- Pre-bundled school supplies.  everything on your child's list comes pre packaged at no extra cost- very convenient.

 

AGAIN PLEASE NOTE: these were prices we found in each store on the day we shopped.  Not responsible for outdated signage or incorrect shelf/scanner pricing.

9 Comments |  Add a Comment

Member Comments Total Comments: 9
Page 1 of 1
superman read my blog view my photos
Aug 12, 2008 | 9:42 PM

CHECK OUT TARGET

terrellmom read my blog view my photos
Aug 13, 2008 | 6:44 AM

I buy school supplies for my kids at walmart every year...this year they seemed cheaper than they have in previous years. I was surprised as i didn't think anything went down in price. Between clothes and supplies for 2 kids i spend a little under a thousand dollars at the beginning of the school year so i'm grateful walmart brought supply costs down this year

furbie read my blog view my photos
Aug 13, 2008 | 10:03 AM

Wal Mart proves it : China rules the market !

mindymc
Aug 13, 2008 | 7:29 PM

For serious bargain shoppers, school supply sales start right around the 4th of July.

I have to seriously laugh at Kroger's "no extra charge" comment. Their supply packs are easily double what I paid for school supplies for my 2nd grader. If you want convenience and a good price, head to Walmart. Just know that their price-match is on identical items (must be the same brand) and you have to have the ad with you.

For office supply stores, Office Max has the worst prices and deals. Office Depot and Staples have had some great penny deals - with nothing extra to buy to get the penny items.

My son's school sells a package deal on school supplies for $45. So just for grins, I budgeted $45 for school supplies to see how much that would get me if I kept my eyes open for the deals. His supplies cost about $23 and would have cost less if I had waited for the deals on a couple of items. Here's what I got:

Pencils 60 ct
Handwriting Tablet
Pencil Sharpener x2
Pink eraser 2pack x5
Wide Rule Filler Paper x5
Plastic 2pocket portfolio x10
White posterboard x5
Mechanical Pencils 5-pk
Crayola Marker 20ct fine point
Pilot G2 Pen
Pencil box x2
9x12 Manila paper
2 pocket folders with prongs x40
protractors x5
rulers x10
12-pack pencil eraser caps x5
12x18 Manila paper
single subject spirals x26
5" scissors x3
Dry erase markers 8ct
Puffs tissues x3
1" Poly Binders x8
8-pk pencils x4
pkg disinfectant wipes
Gallon size 24 ct ziplocs x2
pkg 12x18 construction paper
pkg 9x18 construction paper
plastic portfolio with pockets and prongs
composition

mindymc
Aug 13, 2008 | 7:29 PM

I guess I bought too much LOL

composition notebook
Elmers glue x2
24ct Crayola crayons x2
12ct Crayola colored pencils x2
10ct Crayola markers x3
Crayola watercolors

ChatterBug read my blog view my photos
Aug 13, 2008 | 11:26 PM

the cheapest deal in town....
dallas mayor school school supplies drive gives out free supplies...
don't work, be on welfare, get more free stuff for being here illegally...ya know, teach your kids where all the handouts are.
isn't that truly the best deal in town?
i don't give to charities anymore with the exception of a very few. i'm tired of my hard earned money going to those who can work, but don't, or those who are here illegally!
sad isn't it?

moankie82 read my blog
Aug 14, 2008 | 4:05 AM

Right furbie. Especially pencils are cheaper. They have the lead built in.

SwimCoachMom
Aug 16, 2008 | 9:41 AM

What about Staples? Look at their ad for 1 cent items this week! Target wasn't too far off walmart pricing overall, either - in some cases, better (in an atmosphere most mom's prefer to walmart).

kathyintex
Aug 16, 2008 | 10:12 AM

I used to shop for most everything at Target or Kroger - HATED Walmart and the way it "felt and looked". BUt, one day needed to buy dog food quickly and was driving by Walmart so I went in. My dog food was five ($5) dollars cheaper there than at my Kroger store or Target. I began looking at the prices of things I buy regularly - every item was at least one dollar less at Walmart. I am a Walmart shopper now, why walk away from money in my family's pocket just because I don't like the way it "feels". I go early, about 8 a.m to shop and it's not crowded or crazy. Just DON'T go on a weekend!

Page 1 of 1


Write your comment below:




Steve_Noviello

It may seem like a heavily pre-produced comment, but I really DO love hearing from our viewers. The segments I do on FOX4 (On Your Side, Save Me Steve, and Deal or Dud) are all about helping you live better day to day. Many of my story ideas come from folks like you- my work is really YOUR work. I’m here to save you time, save you money and save you from getting ripped off. OK, now that all of that formal stuff is out of the way- here’s a little about me. Yes, I’m a Yankee- born and raised in New York, I love living in North Texas, it is so refreshing to be in a place where people are proud of the heritage years of rich history have created. Back at home in NY the tie that binds very often is the lack thereof – really, nobody is REALLY from NY anymore it seems. What’s that you say? There’s nothing to do in North Texas except shop and eat? PERFECT! Those are my two favorite things! When I’m not at work and not eating or shopping (bargain hunting is more like it) you’ll find me walking my dog Parker (that’s his picture - we got him at the Weim Rescue of North Texas), inappropriately using the punctuation “…”, or driving with the top down and pretending I know the lyrics to whatever song I’m listening to. If you drive by and catch me… no laughing!

Member Since: 5/25/2006